"The obligation of the Seller or Purchaser to close the transaction contemplated by this Agreement is contingent upon the specific approval by FSTC."
That sentence comes from a 2022 purchase agreement for a leasehold parcel in Fairhope. The buyer was the University of South Alabama, and the agreement is part of a public board of trustees packet. The price was $1,717,000. The university paid cash and needed no mortgage. Even so, the deal could close only after a third party approved it. That third party was the Fairhope Single Tax Corporation, the landowner, and it was neither the buyer nor the seller.
Single Tax homes involve both a house and a land lease. The lease, the landowner's approval and the annual land rent can each hold up a closing. A buyer who learns this during the inspection period has much less time to deal with it than a buyer who learns it before writing the offer.
What changes hands, and what stays with the Colony
The Fairhope Single Tax Corporation, which locals often call the Colony, owns about 4,500 acres in and around Fairhope. Its own site puts that at roughly 25% of the city. Most of the land is downtown and to the east along Fairhope Avenue. Lessees get a renewable 99-year lease on the land and own the improvements on it.
The structure goes back to 1894. That year a group from Des Moines, Iowa, led by Ernest B. Gaston, founded the colony on the land-value theories of economist Henry George. Fairhope is one of two single tax colonies left in the country. The other is Arden, Delaware. The corporation is still active. Fairhope Museum of History director Gabriel Gold-Vukson told WKRG in March 2025 that the corporation "still exists, it still functions. We just had elections, it's got members." In that interview he put the holdings at about 4,000 acres, a bit below the corporation's own figure.
In the 2022 university deal, the buyer didn't take over the rest of the seller's term. The seller assigned its existing lease and conveyed the improvements, and the buyer got a new 99-year ground lease from FSTC. The agreement also made the property subject to FSTC's Constitution and By-Laws, along with the Alabama statutes it cited. That's one documented transfer, a commercial cash purchase. FSTC's public homepage doesn't post a standard procedure for residential transfers or a fee schedule.
The lease becomes part of the collateral
Most of the friction in a financed purchase starts here. A lender on a Single Tax home has no land to lend against. It lends against the improvements and your rights under the lease. Fannie Mae's leasehold guidelines, updated August 5, 2026, require the loan to be a first lien on both. Those guidelines also require a few things from the lease itself:
| Fannie Mae leasehold requirement |
|---|
| All rents and assessments that have come due under the lease must be paid |
| The lease must not be in default, and the lessor must not have claimed a default |
| The lease must be recorded in the land records |
| The unexpired term must run at least five years past the loan's maturity |
| The lease must allow assignment, transfer and mortgage without restriction, or for a reasonable fee and reasonable documentation |
Fairhope Mortgage, a local mortgage broker, says plainly that these homes can be financed. Depending on the borrower, the property and the lease, that can include conventional, FHA and VA loans. The same lender says FSTC documentation has historically included an "assent to mortgage." The lender also warns that not every lender knows the structure. One that doesn't may treat the lot as ordinary rented land.
Where the approval clause meets the loan rules
Here two sets of rules can pull against each other. Fannie Mae says a borrower's lease "must not require a credit review or impose other qualifying criteria on any assignee, transferee, mortgagee, or sublessee." The 2022 FSTC transfer made closing contingent on "specific approval by FSTC." It also required the seller to deliver "all documents reasonably required by FSTC" and an assignment "satisfying the reasonable requirements of FSTC."
In the university deal, the title commitment called for an owner's leasehold title insurance policy from Commonwealth Land Title Insurance Company. It was written on the ALTA standard leasehold form and covered the full purchase price.
The lease and the appraisal
The appraisal is part of this too. Fannie Mae's leasehold appraisal rules require the appraiser to describe the lease's terms and restrictions in a written addendum. The appraiser must also discuss what effect, if any, those terms have on the home's value and marketability. When there are enough closed sales with similar leases, the appraiser has to use them. If there aren't, the appraiser can use fee-simple sales but must explain why and adjust for the difference in property rights.
This matters for anyone setting a price. A Single Tax house on a street of fee-simple homes isn't automatically comparable to its neighbors. How the appraiser handles the lease affects the value the lender will lend against.
Single Tax rent and the 2026 invoice
The carrying cost works differently too. On a Single Tax home, the yearly bill you pay is FSTC "rent." The Alabama Supreme Court's 1987 opinion in Fairhope Single Tax Corp. v. Rezner quoted the standard lease as it stood then. Annual rent was the rental value of the land, not counting the lessee's improvements, as set by the corporation's Executive Council or Board of Directors. A 2020 Explore Eastern Shore explainer said the rent includes taxes on the land and improvements, an administration fee and a fee based on the land's appraised value. The 2025 WKRG piece said taxes are paid on the leased land and not on the structures. FSTC's homepage doesn't publish its current formula. For a specific house, the real number is on that lease's invoice.
The 2026 invoices are already out. The 2% discount for paying in full ended November 2. Without the discount, full payment is due December 1, 2026. The 2022 agreement conveyed the property subject to "FSTC rents and ad valorem taxes for the year of the conveyance." Who pays the 2026 rent, and how it's split at closing, is a question for the contract and the closing attorney. It needs an answer before closing day.
The mailing address is changing as well. Starting January 1, 2027, FSTC asks for mail at 10 N Summit Street. That's the former Fairhope library, which the corporation built in 1908. Gulf Coast Media reported in February that FSTC is renovating it for offices, meeting space and archives. Anyone sending transfer documents or payments around the new year should check which address to use.
On the loan side, the local lender notes that recurring lease obligations can count toward the housing expense used to qualify you, together with insurance and any HOA dues.
All of this is general information and not legal, tax or financial advice. A real estate attorney, lender or tax professional can confirm how these rules apply to your own purchase.
Questions buyers ask about Single Tax homes
How do I tell whether a Fairhope house is on Colony land? You can't tell from the street, and many Fairhope homes are ordinary fee-simple property. It shows up in the title and the lease records for that property.
Can I use a VA or FHA loan? Both programs allow eligible leaseholds, and the lease, the property and the transaction have to meet the program's rules. Your lender should review the lease early in the process.
If you're looking at a house on Colony land, Luker Smith can help you collect the lease, the invoice and FSTC's approval steps and look over the house itself. Let's Connect.